Category Archives: Reflections

New Tools for Citizen Journalism: #NCMR Reflections

This is the third in a series of posts reflecting on lessons I’ve learned through my work as an AmeriCorps VISTA at CAN TV and my time spent at the 2011 National Conference on Media Reform (NCMR).

One of the most fundamental questions “the media” face is how to meaningfully engage the legions of bloggers, YouTubers and other users who are now undeniably a part of the club. For many, the answer is giving these individuals the tools they need to convert from mere “bloggers” to true “citizen journalists.” Which begs another question: what the heck is a citizen journalist?

The answer offered by many of the panelists at the “Creating and Sustaining Citizen Journalism” workshop was that any amateur (as in unpaid) person engaging in an act of journalism- shooting video, gathering interviews, writing articles- can rightfully be called a “citizen journalist.” Instead of seeing these individuals as the competition, most outlets are searching for ways to bring them into the fold. One compelling model demonstrated by Jason Barnett of is “citizen-fueled news.” In The Uptake’s newsroom, citizen journalists are given different roles based on their experience level and individual interests. Entry-level reporters are given the  “witness” title, where their main responsibility is to gather raw information and stream video live from  newsworthy events. Then journalists in the newsroom and others watching the footage online make note of interesting clips from the video and turn those into stories. This can lead to some compelling front-line type coverage and can paint a more complete picture of events as they unfold.

For instance, the video below, from protests at the 2008 Republican National Convention, was streamed live even as protestors (and the producer) were hit with tear gas. Barnett added that this approach also has the added value that their videos can’t be confiscated by police- which is an issue in such scenarios.

In addition to providing the raw material needed for stories, citizen journalists can also help fill the gaps in media coverage that many communities face. Nicole Belanger of Cambridge Community Television said that her Cambridge has no local newspaper or television station so their access center established NeighborMedia,  a community-driven news website. By providing training in reporting and writing, CCTV works with citizen journalists to produce quality stories and cover the local issues that interest them. This support includes one-on-one training, access to equipment, and other services. According to Belanger, their goal is to “Provide citizens with the tools to be civically active,” and build a bridge between their public access tv channel and their website. NeighborMedia has been pretty successful, with people from the community submitting stories on a wide range of issues.

I think this approach also reconciles to a certain degree issues that the Huffington Post and other mainstream outlets fail to address: incentives and compensation. By offering free training and access to equipment, media access centers are investing in their people just as their reporters invest their time and effort into producing content. While in an ideal world they would be paid for their work, there is definitely a value to the professional skills that they can develop as a result.

Finally, an advantage of working with citizen journalists addresses a core issue all journalists face: access. Carlos Pareja of Peoples Production House pointed out that citizen journalists can often have access to communities that reporters don’t. Think of the kind of access a young person has in talking to their peers, versus a professional reporter talking to them. Obviously, they can get a more candid response. They also possess a deeper understanding of the communities they’re covering, and this can add a great degree of depth and background to their coverage.

All in all, I think citizen journalists are already contributing a great deal today’s “media” as it is, but in order to gain the most benefit from them (and mitigate any harms), it’s vital to provide them with the structure, know-how, and tools they need to contribute. This is a unique niche that I think many community media organizations are beginning to fill, and while there’s probably no one “correct” solution, we are already benefiting from their stories and passion.

Key Points:

  • Different levels of content contribution make it easier for users to “dip their toes in”
  • In distributing content, build different user profiles and ask with surveys, dedicate different content to each platform
  • While citizen journalism initiatives can be started by anyone, they gain access and credibility through affiliations with “mainstream” established journalistic institutions
  • The entire process should be transparent and distributive, sharing the work load with users


“Content is king but collaboration is Queen” -Susan Mernit, Oakland Local

“First ask the community what they want, and then build it,” Kwan Booth (@Boothism), Oakland Local


Leave a comment

Filed under Journalism, Non-Profit, Reflections, VISTA

Open Source as a Philosophy: #NCMR Reflections

This is the first of a series of posts reflecting on lessons I’ve learned through my work as an AmeriCorps VISTA at CAN TV and my time spent at the 2011 National Conference on Media Reform (NCMR) back in April.

I’ve been getting more and more into open source through working at CAN TV and seeing the great work that the Open Media Foundation and others are doing in the media access community using open source software. “Open source,” if you don’t know, is basically a collaborative method of development. Instead of being held as a secret, the blueprints for open source products are shared so that others can copy, mash up, and then improve them; they ultimately share them back with the community. The more people that participate the better the product becomes, and the more everyone benefits.

Open source is usually associated with software, but the same principles are applied to other products as well. As one of the panelists on the Open Sourcing Community Media panel, Craig Sinclair of Amherst media, said, “Open source is as much about philosophy as it is about technology.” This was a lesson that I thought is one that all nonprofits should take to heart. So many problems organizations face on a day-to-day basis are shared by hundreds, possibly thousands of nonprofits. And yet, their solutions to those problems are often not shared. Each organization eventually re-invents its own version of the wheel. Through a more open source-style approach, each individual action can benefit the common good.

As far as community media organizations are concerned, many are looking to open source tools as a way to engage in “broadercasting,” or using digital tools to expand the reach of public content. Fellow DASCorps VISTA Anne Jonas showcased Miro Community, a very cool tool for creating community video websites. I’ve been experimenting with it for CAN TV and I think there’s great potential. While it’s easy to find videos for any interest, it’s hard to find any that are truly local. By bringing these videos under one roof, Miro helps make the Internet local. Jen Gilomen of the Bay Area Video Coalition (BAVC) showed how they use open source tools in their access center to manage equipment, upload videos to their website, and have them backed up digitally. These tools, of course, were first developed by people other than BAVC, and after making some improvements on its own, BAVC shared them back with the community. Thus it comes full circle.

Key Points:

  • Community Media centers need to be a “hub” of media production online and offline, a key component of the “new localism”
  • Need to develop media that connects, educates, empowers, and enables people to produce content.
  • “Open Source” isn’t limited to software- increasingly, open source is for hardware too.


“Community Media Centers should be a testing ground for all these new ideas.”

Leave a comment

Filed under Journalism, Non-Profit, Reflections, VISTA

What Volunteering Means: MLK Day Reflections

The following is cross-posted from Compassion Takes Action, the blog at The Volunteer Center of Northwest Suburban Chicago, where I currently work as an Americorps VISTA

As a part of Martin Luther King, Jr. Day on Monday, volunteers turned out all over the country to “Make it a day on, not a day off,” working to bring the philosophy of MLK to life through their service. There was many volunteer projects going on throughout our community and thousands happening around the country. It’s always refreshing to see the spirit of service move so many people. Even President Obama got involved, serving food to the homeless in Washington, D.C.

I joined the other VISTAs from here at TVC in volunteering at Little City, an organization that serves people with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Some of us worked in the Encore retail shop, helping to hang, sort and price everything from 1980′s-era clothing to heavy crystal ash trays. Others worked in Little City’s book warehouse, helping to sort the piles of donated literature. And while it was difficult for the bibliophiles among us to part with some of the books (like VISTA Olesya in the video), we all understood that our work was contributing to a great organization and a great cause.

Working for a non-profit that promotes volunteering in the community, I’ve definitely come to appreciate the huge impact that volunteers have on the community. To think of how much it would cost organizations to pay people to do the work that volunteers happily do for free makes it clear that so many organizations wouldn’t be able to do so much good in our community if it weren’t for volunteers. So thank you to everyone who turned out.

The quote of the day definitely goes to Nancy Levi, a former schoolteacher and the volunteer helping to lead Little City’s book sorting operation. As she put it, “Volunteering is the rent you pay for your space on Earth.” I couldn’t agree more.

Leave a comment

Filed under Non-Profit, Reflections